Jackie Parry – author

Which Boat?

8 Comments

Your boat becomes your world, town, village, home, sanctuary. There is no such thing as a perfect boat, and you will always make at the very minimum one or two compromises when you make your purchase.

If you intend to cruise long-term, do not forget to consider the boat’s ability to be your home. There are used boats out there to suit any budget.

Our second boat Pyewacket had plenty of space for 'work' and living.

Our second boat Pyewacket had plenty of space for ‘work’ and living.

Which boat building material is better?

With a plethora of different boat materials, design, layout, length etc., our suggestion for which material to buy is to buy a boat built of material you like, or can handle working with.

They all have their pros and cons:

Timber

Pros: Light, strong, attractive, easy to work

Cons: Rot, dents easily, many parts make the whole unit

Composite – usually molded lightweight timber and epoxy resigns

Pros: Light, strong, low maintenance, no electrolysis

Cons: Not a strong as steel, especially pin-point loads

Mariah II, our first boat, a composite build and cutter rigged sloop.

Mariah II, our first boat, a composite build and cutter rigged sloop.

Ferro

Pros: Cheap

Cons: Undetected terminal damage, due to rust, a possibility. Poor resale

Fibreglass

Pros: Strong, light, modular construction

Cons: Osmosis, UV deterioration

Pyewacket II, fibreglass and cutter rigged too.

Pyewacket II, fibreglass and cutter rigged too.

Aluminium

Pros: Best strength to weight ratio of the commonly used metals, easier to work with than steel

Cons: Electrolysis: constant monitoring of electrolysis is required (e.g. earth leakages in power circuit). Galvanic Corrosion: don’t drop a coin or sinker in the bilge, as it will corrode the aluminium

Steel

Pros: Strong, easy to repair

Cons: Maintenance, rust, heavy

When looking at boats you obviously see what needs doing, but start asking pertinent questions or thinking along the lines of what you don’t see. There are always hidden surprises. If you see a lot of work, that will only be a part of what actually is required.

All jobs on the boat take much more time than you think. Give a job a time, double it, then treble it and then you are nearly half way to estimating the time the job will take.

Size

Previously we talked about the rough calculation (in our opinion) of a size of a boat being 10 feet per decade of your age (see previous article here).

In our twenties, it always made us feel better that we were the smallest at all the anchorages, we thought bigger boats were too big to handle for two, more expensive etc. In our middle age, several years later we leapt up to 51’ (by accident really). Pyewacket handled better than Mariah (our first boat of 33 ft) under sail and motor, she was far easier to dock. As for reefing there was no difference, it was just as easy on Pyewacket as it was on Mariah . . . in fact in some cases it was slightly less of struggle (in big seas). Pyewacket had a kinder motion and bum bars to lean on (next to the mast).

Costs

We’ve already written a fair bit about the costs (see link to article above). However don’t forget, the marina fees will be more for a larger boat, (and hauling out). But with hard work and constant maintenance on both our boats, we noticed that Pyewacket (51 ft) was not significantly more expensive than Mariah (33 ft) …  all in all an eye opener for us.

Pyewacket II - 51' and not significantly dearer!

Pyewacket II – 51′ and not significantly more expensive, however, a fair bit deeper at 2 metres (compared with Mariah’s 1.5 metres)

Make some savings with a bigger boat

We actually made some savings, having a larger boat:

Pyewacket sailed so much better to windward so we used far less diesel than we did on Mariah*.

We had far more storage for storing long-term foods and spare parts. We carried incredible amounts of water, so it didn’t matter that we didn’t have a water-maker or that we didn’t see land for months. (We could also collect rain water very easily – more on that another day).

*(I know, I know – it’s a sailboat, why do we run the engine? Well, at times there is no wind (or very little) and swells in the ocean, this can create a horrid motion on board, which is not only uncomfortable but damaging. As the boat rolls, the sails ‘slat’, or ‘bang’ from side to side as there is not enough wind to keep them full. This stress on the sails is very damaging and ultimately could end up costing you more than the diesel you use to counteract the rolling motion. At these times we would run the engine at very low revs, just enough to settle the boat’s motion, protect our sails and have a bit of comfort on board.

Storage

Considerations:

  • where the dinghy is to be stowed
  • the outboards
  • dive gear
  • spares
  • food
  • linen
  • towels
  • toilet rolls
  • sails
  • lines
  • clothes
  • beer
  • books
  • laptops and printers
  • charts
  • fenders
  • sewing machine
  • vacuum
  • cleaning gear
  • bathroom gear
  • shoes
  • dirty laundry…

There is no ‘right’ kind or size of boat. Our preference is on the heavier side. As well as type, design, materials, think ‘layout’ as you are going to be living on this boat for some time. In our opinion a ‘big’ bathroom looks good but is really a waste of space.

Poled out on Mariah.

Poled out on Mariah.

Rig

Different types of rig are linked with different types of boat. For example a schooner and a ketch have different aerodynamic properties, which make them more suitable to certain types of boating. A racing boat will have different aerodynamics than a cruiser. Ensure the rig is fitted according to the design of the boat. Double mast rigs allow different sail plans. Cutter rigging on the foremast is ideal for carrying a storm jib and is strong.

A Schooner has beauty, but is it manageable? Popular choices are sloop and cutter. Both our boats were cutter-rigged sloops which worked for us (furling jib, hanked-on staysail and full battened main).

The missen on a ketch or schooner take up a lot of room, usually reducing cockpit comfort.

Can you cope?

If there are just two of you on board, you are effectively single-handed for at least eight hours a day. What if something happens to your partner? Can you handle the rig? Not just when there is a 15-knot breeze, your partner may be incapacitated in a storm, can you handle everything then?

Keels

Full keel:

  • less manoeuvrability in port (wider turning circle, when applying astern propulsion it could go anywhere – probably into the wind)
  • more stable
  • take grounding better
  • can help protect prop from debris
  • don’t point very well
  • less likely, in our opinion, to broach
A good depth, 1.5 metres on Mariah. This meant we could get into fantastic ports such as Aitutaki.

A good depth, 1.5 metres on Mariah. This meant we could get into fantastic ports such as Aitutaki.

Fin keels:

  • more on performance boats
  • more efficient
  • point better
  • less structurally sound
  • grounding could result in major damage

We’ve listed two extremes here, of course there are many choices ‘between’ these. Study, research and figure out what you want to do. If you just want to do bay sailing on the weekend you would want a fin keel. If you are serious about blue water cruising, think full keel, or something close to it.

For cruising try to avoid ‘a fat-arsed’ boat, they are tempting for storage but enhance the vessel’s desire to broach.

Pyewacket's great cockpit 'stored' many people!

Pyewacket’s great cockpit ‘stored’ many people!

Then there’s depth . . . the deeper the boat the more restricted you are into some ports/anchorages… but that is not a top-list item for us – safety & comfort come first.

With some of the technical aspects tackled here – don’t forget the boat will become your home. The considerations are endless. Our book Cruiser’s AA will tell you much more.

Mariah was small (33ft) but very roomy and comfortable.

Mariah was small (33ft) but very roomy and comfortable.

Advertisements

Author: jackieandnoel

Author and Traveller

8 thoughts on “Which Boat?

  1. Wise words as always! 🙂

    Like

  2. Very nice checklist. We too just kind of fell into each boat upgrade over the years and did find it much easier to sail our current 54 over the 42 we previously owned.

    Like

  3. If money had been no object I would have wanted an aluminum boat. Nice informative post for the boat shopper. I’m impressed with the space on that 33 foot you had.

    Like

    • Thanks Melissa, we met people who were really happy with their aluminium boat – got the strength and the light displacement. And for us, yes, Mariah had great space, the flush decks helped! Glad you liked the article!

      Like

  4. GOOD guildelines here, Jackie and Noel. Our custom steel cutter 46 feet, built in Australia was not heavy, the result of exceptional design and Dutch build…… but it was difficult to keep it in perfect shape in the humid steamy tropics. The interior of the hull was sprayfoamed so insulation was excellent for living on in the Pacific Northwest until we smartened up and followed the sun. Like Elizabeth Taylor used to say about her husbands, *every one was the BEST one and the LAST* (HaHa)

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s